I have mixed feelings. There is no scientific evidence that doing this
for short periods of time like you say, is bad for baby. There
are just no studies--hard medical studies, I mean--to say so.
OTOH, there are professionals who have reasons for thinking it is not a
good idea. Of course, professional opinions come and go, and years ago
they told mothers to not even carry the baby upright until a certain
age.
My feeling is this--the way a baby is held in a carrier should mimic
the way you would hold the baby in your arms. If I hold my baby facing
out, I would never hold him with his legs hanging straight down like
those instructions you are referring to. If DH or I hold him facing
outfor a few minutes, we will naturally be using a second arm under his
bottom to give support there, and keep his legs up--like a sitting
position instead of a dangling position. So I generally don't do the
dangly position, but if baby does want to see out better for a few
minutes in a MT, pouch, RS, or wrap, I would use the buddha carry where
he is facing mostly forward but with legs tucked up in front of him.
You can also do this with baby sitting sideways, so he can still see
you but also see out.
Kim
mama to 2 boys--a peanut and a preschooler