in

Do you stick strictly to ASL signs only?

Last post 03-26-2006, 10:33 AM by dnield. 5 replies.
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  03-07-2006, 11:09 PM 13234

    Do you stick strictly to ASL signs only?

    I know some are kind of hard for baby to do so I'm wondering how much flexability ya'll have with it. I've read good information either way.


    Ann

    Mommy to Logan 8-25-05
  •  03-08-2006, 11:00 AM 13254 in reply to 13234

    Re: Do you stick strictly to ASL signs only?

    That was our intentions.

    Although Satori has picked up a few signs I think that are not ASL, and has "modified" some signs so they are easier for her to do... :)


    Angela
    Mama to Satori (11/04)
  •  03-08-2006, 12:07 PM 13256 in reply to 13234

    Re: Do you stick strictly to ASL signs only?

    We try to do most signs ASL but at only 18 months our daughter doesn't have the finger dexterity (and won't probably for awhile) to make them perfectly. Therefore we have modified many to be easier for her. And the purpose of the signing anyway is so she can communicate her needs and for us to understand her so- it works out to be a win/win situation for us.
  •  03-08-2006, 4:35 PM 13271 in reply to 13256

    Re: Do you stick strictly to ASL signs only?

    We stick to ASL but DS modifies the heck out of them.  He likes to sign letters of the alphabet but his a, e, m, n, s all look the same as "a".  I try to model the right way to do it (it would be nice if others could understand him but who am I kidding, how many people can sign?  LOL.)

    mom to DS (march 2003) and DD (may 2005)
  •  03-08-2006, 9:51 PM 13285 in reply to 13271

    Re: Do you stick strictly to ASL signs only?

    We also tried to stick to ASL at first. Each child has made up their own signs and adapted them to meet their needs. I think it is creative and smart to change signs.
    Beth
  •  03-26-2006, 10:33 AM 13842 in reply to 13234

    Re: Do you stick strictly to ASL signs only?

    We also stick to ASL.  DS modifies them but eventually tends to use the actual sign.  It is just like his speech.  My stepbrother and SIL are deaf and so I wanted to use the actual language rather than the baby sign version because then it will be useful when we get together with them and their friends (they lipread and use spoken words, but I know it makes their lives easier if we can sign some things.  Plus, it thrills my stepbrother that we are learning it).

    I had a lot of friends use the modified version of more when teaching their DCs.  We used the ASL version.  DS started signing more the modified way and eventually moved to the ASL way as he got older.  I just try to understand what he is signing.


    Dorothy
View as RSS news feed in XML